RAF Chinook crash families demand independent review from Andy 2026

The families of those killed in the 1994 RAF Chinook crash on the Mull of Kintyre have called on Andy Burnham to launch an independent review into the disaster. Twenty-nine military personnel died when the helicopter went down during a flight from Northern Ireland. The two pilots were initially blamed but later exonerated after a 2011 inquiry failed to determine the cause. Now, former Defence Secretary Liam Fox has voiced "deep concerns" that vital information may have been withheld, fueling allegations of a cover-up.

Why an independent review is needed now

More than three decades later, the Chinook Justice Campaign (CJC), representing over 55 family members of 25 victims, is pushing for a fresh probe independent of the Ministry of Defence (MoD). A high court judge recently blocked a legal claim against the MoD due to the passage of time, but the CJC plans to take the case to the European Court of Human Rights. Matt Tobias, whose father Lt Col John Tobias died in the crash, stated: "We do not want years of further litigation. We urge Mr. Burnham to meet us within his first 100 days in office."

Key demands from the families

• An independent review free from MoD influence
• Full disclosure of all airworthiness records related to the Chinook HC2
• A public acknowledgment of the cover-up and a strengthened duty of candour

Timeline of the disaster and cover-up claims

What Liam Fox has said

Former Conservative Defence Secretary Liam Fox, who ordered the 2011 review, now backs the call for a fresh independent investigation. He stated there is a "strong enough belief" that a deliberate cover-up occurred, and that MoD details on the Chinook's airworthiness "were not correct." This adds weight to the families' argument that official secrecy has hidden the truth for decades.

How Andy Burnham can make a difference

Burnham, known for his stance against cover-up culture in government, has the power to commission an independent review without waiting for the courts. The families point to his House of Commons speech about ending secrecy and strengthening the duty of candour as a source of hope. By ordering a review, Burnham could set a precedent for transparency and justice for all victims of state secrecy.

FAQ

The families' call for an independent review has gained political backing and public sympathy. As the case moves toward the European Court of Human Rights, Andy Burnham's response could determine whether the truth finally emerges or remains buried under decades of official secrecy.