Daughter Wants To Put Down Old Suffering Dog Against Father’s Wishes, Asks If She’s Doing The Right Thing 2026

The emotional connection people have with their pets is immeasurable and losing one is never easy. It can be difficult to determine exactly when the pain is greatest – watching them lose their vitality, suffering from an illness, or passing away suddenly. One heartbreaking story following this theme on Reddit’s AITA forum gained popularity: a young woman wanting to euthanize a 17-year-old family pet who is in a severe situation physically, despite her father’s strong objections. OP also offers updates on the situation in this text post. Keep on scrolling to read the full story down below!

Source: u/Nightstar95

#1) Would OP be in the wrong for putting down the family dog?

#2) OP and her parents have a dog called Simba whose health has been deteriorating this past year.

#3) Simba is too old for a surgery so they had opted to just treat his pain but his condition later became very severe.

#4) Simba’s painkillers don’t work anymore and often OP finds him screaming in pain.

#5) OP and her mother believe Simba should be put down now but her father disagrees.

#6) OP’s dad is from an older generation that doesn’t condone euthanasia but OP and her mother feel that it needs to be done.

#7) OP gives an update, letting us know that Simba will be euthanized.

#8) OP and her mother decided to call the local vet and if her father disagrees further, they’ll take Simba to the clinic and get him put down there.

#9) Simba was responding well to medications but slowly began deteriorating.

#10) OP tried convincing her parents for ages but only now had her mom agreed to this.

#11) The vet decided Simba can be managed with more intensive care and shouldn’t be put down.

#12) OP was unhappy about the situation but the vet insisted it was normal.

#13) Simba was finally put down.

The grief we feel when we lose our beloved pets is debilitating at the very least. However, sometimes difficult decisions must be made in order to ensure the ultimate well-being of our animals. Dogs often have difficulty expressing their discomfort and pain, so it’s important to keep an eye on them and observe any changes in behavior or symptoms that may indicate might need to see a veterinarian It’s important to act quickly and provide them with proper treatment if needed. Here’s what other Reddit users are saying about this situation:

#14) It really is cruel when it could be over sooner and painlessly.

Via KatarinaRen

#15) Absolutely spot on.

Via plfntoo

#16) Lying might be the best solution here, NGL.

Via NorthernLitUp

This was a pretty loaded one. What is your opinion on this? Have you had any similar experiences? Drop a comment down below and let us know! Stay tuned for more.